[A few days ago, my tasting group met up to taste some German Riesling. Each of the wines were covered with a brown bag. The line-up was, as you will see, quite focused. Thank you to my fellow tasters for putting up with my laptop and keyboard strokes during the proceedings. And a special thank you to Nadia for putting together a very solid line-up]
So here we go, flight one of our group's Riesling tasting. Group is discussing the vagaries of auto correct on smart phones. Wines A, B, C and D are now in the glass. Lots of swirling, sniffing, slurping, spitting. Time to catch up myself.
A - Cool toned, slight medicinal edged aromas, combined with SO2. Initially, not a lot of depth aromatically. Improves with air. Yellow fruits. Lemon-lime Elegant and understated, slightly herbal/bitter edge. Ruwer kabinett?
B - spicy, slightly sweet smelling apples. Red slate, here? Most expressive nose. Very good intensity and presence, and juicy acidity.
C - Talcum powder and appley nose. Creamy, slightly leesy wine here. Mellow acids. Young Kabinett?
D - Whoa. Clearly a more mature wine here. A sweeter pradikat, hitting some petrol notes now on the nose. More lemon-lime soda. An easy drinker for those who like RS, but it's simple.
We are deciding whether or not to rank the wines. Always a subject of debate with this group. Someone jokingly references the oft stated "it [blind tasting] is a parlor game." Arjun wants everyone to know that 'B' is his least favorite. We are unanimously united against 'D.' Lots of 'C' fans. 'A' and 'B' bring the sulphur.
OK, 'new shit is coming to light' as the Dude once said. 'A' and 'B,' and 'C' and 'D' are from the same vineyard.
'E' - Noticeably darker color than other two. A light gold color. Deep, orchard fresh fruit smells. Honeyed, a bit of botrytis? A bold, rich style. Nice length. Rheingau Spatlese (?)
'F' - Sulphur. Medicinal cherry aromas. Peach pit. Purity is increasing on nose, a bit. Same producer as 'A.' Back to the Ruwer.
'G' - Sulphurous, but less. Ripe pink grapefruits aromas - nice. Juicy citrus, especially pink grapefruit, and good acidity. Wehlener Sonnenuhr? Restrained kabinett.
Someone offers, "I think 'F' is the stinkiest of the two, by far." I agree. More minerality in this flight, Mark offers.
'H' - Too bad this is corked. There is good material here. Great balance, power and acidity. And length.
'I' - Deepest color yet, almost 18K gold. Creamy. Smells mature. Rich, mature spat (auslese?)
Back to that German butter. It came from the Pasta Shop's dairy section at Market Hall in Rockridge.
The wines are revealed:
A - 2009 Prum Graacher Himmelreich Kabinett
B - 2008 Prum Graacher Himmelreich Kabinett
C - 2008 Willi Schaefer Graacher Himmelreich Kabinett
D - 2003 Willi Schaefer Graacher Himmelreich Spatlese
E - 2009 Kerpen Wehlener Sonnenuhr Kabinett
F - 2009 Prum Wehelener Sonnenuhr Kabinett
G - 2008 Prum Wehlener Sonnenuhr Kabinett
H - 2002 Hauth Kerpen Wehlener Sonnenuhr Kabinett
I - 2001 Kerpen Wehlener Sonnenuhr Auslese